Skip to main content

EARLY CONGREGATION

Program
NYS Historic
Subject
Building, Religion
Location
491 Main St, Cairo, NY 12413, USA
Lat/Long
42.299849195285, -73.999429618515
Grant Recipient
Cairo Historical Society
Historic Marker

EARLY CONGREGATION

Inscription

EARLY CONGREGATION
PRESBYTERIAN COMMUNITY
FIRST ORGANIZED 1799 WITH 8
MEMBERS IN ACRA. MOVED TO
CAIRO CA. 1805. SOLD PROPERTY
TO METHODIST CHURCH 1952.
WILLIAM G. POMEROY FOUNDATION 2026

As more people moved into what is now Greene County, NY following the Revolutionary War, they brought their spiritual needs with them, creating demand for new places of worship. One such early resident was Daniel Sayre, who, along with his family, moved into what is now the Town of Cairo in 1794.

Sayre, a Presbyterian, found that his new home did not have a church of that denomination, so he attended Baptist services, until that congregation moved away, leaving few options for Sayre and his fellow congregants. Nevertheless, they kept up their meetings, engaging with the different preachers who would visit and stay in the area. On May 22,1799, the congregation persuaded a man named Reverend Hotchkin, who had been holding semi-regular services, to formally organize a Presbyterian church.

The new church’s eight members originally met at a meetinghouse in the nearby hamlet of Acra before moving to the hamlet of Cairo in 1804, where they began building a new church.

The congregation continued to meet there until 1952, when they sold their property to the Methodist Church, which, as of 2026, still owns it and continues to hold regular services.